CAK warns of jail for supermarkets on unfair buying, lifting small suppliers’ hopes

By Antynet Ford
Avocado oil processor, Mizizi Njiru, who abandoned plan to stock his products in major retail chains after failing to agree viable terms, plans to revive his efforts after the Competition Authority of Kenya (CAK) put retailers on notice that they could be fined up to 10 per cent of their revenues for unfair buying practices.
Mizizi shifted to selling his cosmetic and cooking oils through Instagram and TikTok after a deal with one of the retail supermarket chains in the country collapsed on the failure to reach what Mizizi viewed as viable terms.
“We didn’t get an agreement with the local retailer we approached because one party was benefiting more than the other and thus we had to step aside first,” said Mizizi, speaking to FarmBizAfrica during the AFMASS Food Expo for Kenya and East Africa earlier this year.
But in its latest notice, CAK has called out retailers for abusing their buying powers, citing practices “including delayed payments, unilateral termination or threat of termination of a contract, and …. demand for preferential terms that are unfavorable to suppliers, and limiting suppliers from selling to competing buyers”.
It said it had noted continued instances of “transfer of costs and risks to suppliers, rebate demands, promotional contributions, extended payment periods and unfavourable terms in joint business plans between retailers and their suppliers” that all comprised anti-competitive practices.
The authority has now put supermarkets on notice of stiff penalties for deviating from genuine, good faith negotiations, including fines of up to 10 per cent of the supermarket’s previous year’s revenues, and jail terms of up to five years.
For suppliers such as Mizizu, the solution to the unfair terms was to flip to shows and social media to reach consumers.
“Apart from being at the expo and also shows where we showcase our products and make sales, we sell a lot on TikTok and Instagram,” he said
“The social media sales are good, because in a week, we get over 20 clients making an order especially for the cosmetic avocado oil.”
He has also opened his own shop. “Apart from social media, we have our plant, Mizizi Njiru located in Ruiru, and we also have a shop in the Nairobi CBD, where you can place your orders and we deliver.”
But his next aim is to approach Naivas and Carrefour as a supplier, with the consumer market for avocado oil still underserved.
“They are our first target when we go back, because they seem to listen and negotiate well. Also, after them, we shall target the local mini marts in the estates because that’s where people live. They need avocado oil for cooking and also for salons in the estates.”
The difficulties for farmer suppliers in reaching consumers through the supermarkets has affected the shape of the Kenyan food market, seeing it dominated by imports for all but fresh produce, and slowing the expansion of value addition in the country.
But studies in other markets have found farmers earning 40 per cent to 50 per cent more where they can win retail supply contracts, and well connected local value chains stimulating local growth.
“There have been people asking why we do not export,..but why not sell here in Kenya and pay the normal VAT tax? That is better and we get a little more profit. Also, the process of getting the (export) license and much more, that is still costly and that is why we have chosen to sell locally, because the local market still has more demand as it is underserved, we get people asking why we have not stocked the products in the local retail chains near them.”
Read next
Get your farming news by email.
Free. Market prices, crop news and farmer opportunities, straight to your inbox.
Set county, crops and alerts
Become a free member so weather and saved tools follow your farm profile



