New window from govt in macadamia competition ban

By Antynet Ford
The long-running battle between Kenya’s nut processors, seeking artificially reduced prices through bans on selling nuts elsewhere, and macadamia farmers, now buried in stockpiles after years of rock bottom pricing, has brought a new six-month reprieve for farmers.
The government, this week, announced the extension of controlled exports for a further six months until April 2027, suspending the export ban for that period to clear excessive unsold stocks of nuts.
Farmers and traders claim there is now a Sh5bn stockpile of 30,000 tonnes of unsold macadamia nuts in the country as a consequence of the ban.
This market breakdown, in a high-demand global sector that Kenya has led as the third or fourth largest macadamia producer in the world, has brought losses to thousands of farmers, as well as to the economy, and the trade balance.
It is also raising questions around the oversight of government policy to prevent the institutionalisation of cartels and anti-competitive practices.
In the case of macadamia, the ban was sought by local, politically powerful, nut processors on the basis it was needed to provide them sufficient local supplies of raw nuts for the country to gain from expanded earnings and jobs from their value addition.
Instead, across years where both Kenya’s production of the nuts and world demand have grown much faster than local processing, the ban has led to farmer stockpiles and a collapse in local pricing.
This mismatch has seen the ban applied and lifted repeatedly since its introduction more than 15 years ago, with prices to farmers rising sharply on each occasion where exports were permitted.
During the suspension in 2024, prices went up threefold, with farmers getting from Sh100 to Sh130 per kg, according to reports in The Standard. With the new open window since July this year, traders say farmgate prices have risen from as low as Sh20 to more than Sh100 per kilo.
But the local processors claim this price rise is putting them out of business, whilst traders are saying the exports are barely being approved, even once permitted.
In the lifting of the ban from July to October, the Macadamia Growers Association had expected exports of 14,000 tonnes, but Agriculture and Food Authority (AFA) acting director Calistus Kundu reported that only 700 metric tonnes had been shipped through the Port of Mombasa by the October 10 deadline.
Macadamia Growers Association Vice Chairman Mureithi Gichabi told the Star that while the AFA had allowed the exports, its regulators subsequently blocked the majority of shipments, failing to facilitate the export process, despite exporters incurring costs to assemble and present the nuts for inspection as required.
However, government policy remains firmly aligned with upholding the ban to create manufacturing jobs.
“Continued exports of in-shell macadamia benefits only foreign buyers who use it as a raw material in their manufacturing which eventually competes with Kenya particular for the US, resulting in loss of jobs in Kenya’s manufacturing sector and reduces export earnings since in-shell macadamia nuts fetch much lower prices compared to the kernel,” said the CS for Agriculture Mutahi Kagwe.
There has been no analysis of the job and income losses caused to farmers selling the nuts locally at Sh20, versus abroad for Sh100, or holding almost a year’s worth of supplies unsold.
However, as the ban limps onwards through the 17th disputed year since its first introduction by order in 2009, the unassessed equation remains the same: being extra jobs with the 14 processors and higher per kg export earnings for much lower volumes, versus extreme income losses for thousands of farmers and net export losses by volume.
It is a sum that no one has yet calculated, including the competition authorities, to prove that the anti-competitive ban is a net gain for Kenya, versus a bonus only for the 14 processors.
Read next
Get your farming news by email.
Free. Market prices, crop news and farmer opportunities, straight to your inbox.
Set county, crops and alerts
Become a free member so weather and saved tools follow your farm profile



